In its analysis, the majority of Council found that the complaint should be upheld under Clause 1(a) of the Code, and unanimously held that the complaint should be upheld under Clause 1(e) of the Code. [...] The impression conveyed to Council by the advertisement was that the pregnant woman featured in the billboard advertisement was in the very late stage of her pregnancy. [...] In the unanimous opinion of the members of Council, the claim in question disregarded the reality that by overturning the Criminal Code provisions outlawing abortions in Canada, the Supreme Court of Canada in 1988 imposed new law by which abortion became legal in Canada. [...] The impression conveyed to Council by the combination of the words Page 8 of 20 and the image in this advertisement was that the image was representative of foetuses when they are aborted (an inaccurate and misleading representation), and that all foetuses at all stages of gestation will feel pain if the pregnancy is aborted. [...] Whether a particular advocacy advertisement actually raises an issue under the Code depends on a number of factors such as the context and content of the advertisement, the audience it reaches or is intended to reach, and the medium/media used to deliver the advertisement.
Authors
- Pages
- 20
- Published in
- Canada
Table of Contents
- Upheld Complaints against Anti-Abortion Ads by Ad Standards 1
- 2023 Upheld Complaints 2
- Complaint #21, Heartbeat International 2
- Complaint #20, Kelowna Right to Life Society 3
- 2020 Upheld Complaints 4
- Complaint #19, Right to Life Kent 4
- 2019 Upheld Complaints 5
- Complaint #18, Guelph & Area Right to Life 5
- Complaint #17, Guelph & Area Right to Life 6
- Complaint #16, Kelowna Right to Life Society 7
- 2018 Upheld Complaints 8
- Complaint #15, We Need a Law 8
- Complaint #14, Lethbridge & DistrictPro-Life 8
- 2017 Upheld Complaints 9
- Complaint #13, St. Catharines Right to Life 9
- Complaint #12, Edmonton Prolife 10
- Complaint #11, Canadian Centre for Bio-ethical Reform 11
- Complaint #10, Canadian Centre for Bio-ethical Reform 12
- 2015 Upheld Complaints 12
- Complaint #9, Canadian Centre for Bio-ethical Reform 12
- 2014 Upheld Complaints 13
- Complaint #8, Guelph & Area Right to Life 13
- Complaint #7, Show the Truth 14
- 2012 Upheld Complaints 15
- Complaint #6, Alliance for Life Ontario 15
- 2010 Upheld Complaints 16
- Complaint #5, Alliance for Life Ontario 16
- Complaint #4, Regina Pro-Life 17
- 2009 Upheld Complaints 17
- Complaint #3, Canadian Centre for Bio-Ethical Reform 17
- 2008 Upheld Complaints 19
- Complaint #2, Edmonton Pro-Life 19
- Complaint #1, Manitoba group (unnamed) 20