Authors
- Disclosure Date
- 2024/11/13
- Disclosure Status
- Disclosed
- Doc Name
- Somalia - SEAP
- Lending Instrument
- Investment Project Financing
- Pages
- 17
- Product Line
- Recipient Executed Activities
- Published in
- United States of America
- Rel Proj ID
- SO-Somali Electricity Access Project -- P165497
- TF No/Name
- TF0A9159-SOMALI ELECTRICITY ACCESS PROJECT,TF0A7110-SEAP - Prep&Supervision,TF0A9095-Somaliland Electricity Access Project,TF0B3136-Somali Electricity Access Project Additinal Financing
- Unit Owning
- Infra AFR Energy 1 (IAEE1)
- Version Type
- Final
Table of Contents
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 1
- 1. Project Data 1
- Project ID Project Name 1
- Country Practice AreaLead 1
- LCTF Numbers Closing Date Original Total Project Cost USD 1
- Bank Approval Date Closing Date Actual 1
- IBRDIDA USD Grants USD 1
- Prepared by Reviewed by ICR Review Coordinator Group 1
- 2. Project Objectives and Components 1
- DEVOBJTBL a. Objectives 1
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 2
- A. Electrification of Households and Small Businesses through Standalone Solar Home Systems. 2
- Appraisal cost US3.0 million actual cost US3.11 million 2
- B. Analytical work for enabling electrification through Solar-Powered Hybrid Mini-grids. 2
- Appraisal cost US1.00 million actual cost US0.45 million 2
- C. Technical Assistance Capacity Building and Project Management. 2
- Appraisal cost US1.75 million revised cost at the time of additional financing US3.20 million actual cost US3.36 million 2
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 3
- Revised Components 3
- Project Cost 3
- Financing 3
- Borrowers contribution 3
- Project Restructurings 3
- First Project Restructuring and Additional Financing July 6 2020 Level 2 3
- Second Project Restructuring June 14 2022 Level 2 3
- Dates 3
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 4
- 3. Relevance of Objectives 4
- Rationale 4
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 5
- Rating 5
- 4. Achievement of Objectives Efficacy 5
- Objective 5
- Rationale 5
- Theory of Change of the Project 5
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 6
- Outputs 6
- Grant funding disbursed to solar home system distributors US 6
- Number of households with new stand-alone solar systems 6
- The number of male-owned and female-owned small businesses with new standalone solar system 6
- Generation capacity of energy constructed or rehabilitated MW 6
- Consumer awareness campaigns completed 6
- Number of consultations for men and women 6
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 7
- Percentage of households with new stand-alone solar systems of which headed by female 7
- Separate consultations with women and men prior to and during implementation 7
- Women-targeted in the information and knowledge campaigns delivered 7
- Number of studies on mini-grid sector completed 7
- Completion of Options Analysis for the Electricity Sub-Transmission and Distribution Integrated Development Least Cost Investments for major load centers in Somalia 7
- Complete Strategic Environmental and Social Assessment for the energy sector 7
- Number of Federal Government of Somalia Ministry of Energy and Water Resources staff trained 7
- Number of Government of Somaliland Ministry of Energy and Mineral staff trained 7
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 8
- Outcomes 8
- Number of people provided with new or improved electricity service 8
- Rating 8
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 9
- Rationale 9
- Overall Efficacy Rating 9
- 5. Efficiency 9
- Economic Analysis 9
- Operational and Administrative Efficiency 9
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 10
- Efficiency Rating 10
- Rate Available Point value CoverageScope 10
- 6. Outcome 10
- Outcome Rating 10
- 7. Risk to Development Outcome 10
- Technical 10
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 11
- Maintenance of solar panels and replacement of batteries 11
- Financial constraints in the solar service sector 11
- 8. Assessment of Bank Performance 11
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 12
- Quality-at-Entry Rating 12
- Quality of Supervision Rating 12
- Overall Bank Performance Rating 12
- 9. ME Design Implementation Utilization 12
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 13
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 14
- ME Quality Rating 14
- 10. Other Issues 14
- Environmental Assessment OPBP 4.01 14
- Financial Management 14
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 15
- Procurement 15
- 11. Ratings 15
- Ratings ICR IEG Reason for DisagreementsComment 15
- 12. Lessons 15
- The hiring of expertise at the preparation stage can increase project readiness and avoid implementation delays in an FCV status country. 15
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 16
- The true extent of project outcomes cannot be captured if the project objective is output- oriented. 16
- 13. Assessment Recommended 16
- 14. Comments on Quality of ICR 16
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 17
