Authors
- Disclosure Date
- 2024/10/16
- Disclosure Status
- Disclosed
- Doc Name
- Uzbekistan - Accelerating Uzbekistan's Transition DPO
- Lending Instrument
- Development Policy Lending
- Pages
- 27
- Product Line
- IBRD/IDA
- Published in
- United States of America
- Rel Proj ID
- UZ-Accelerating Uzbekistan'S Transition Development Policy Operati -- P176353
- Unit Owning
- EFI-ECA-MTI-MacroFiscal-1 (EECM1)
- Version Type
- Final
Table of Contents
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 1
- 1. Operation Information 1
- Operation ID Operation Name 1
- Country Practice Area Lead 1
- Non-Programmatic DPF 1
- LCTF Numbers Closing Date Original Total Financing USD 1
- Bank Approval Date Closing Date Actual 1
- IBRDIDA USD Co-financing USD 1
- Prepared by Reviewed by ICR Review Coordinator Group 1
- 2. Program Objectives and PillarsPolicy Areas 1
- DEVOBJTBL a. Objectives 1
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 2
- PDO1 2
- PDO2 2
- PDO3 2
- Stronger Market Institutions and Better Management of State-Owned Enterprises 2
- Improved Fiscal Transparency and Accountability 2
- Increased Economic and Social Inclusion 2
- Program Cost and Financing. 2
- Dates. 2
- 3. Relevance of Design 2
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 3
- Binding Constraints to Development. 3
- Systematic Country Diagnostic for Uzbekistan 3
- Country Development Priorities. 3
- Development Strategy for New Uzbekistan 2022-2026 3
- World Bank Group WBG Country Strategy. 3
- Performance and Learning Review PLR for the Country Partnership Framework CPF for Uzbekistan for the period FY16-FY20 3
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 4
- CPF for the Republic of Uzbekistan for the period FY2022-FY2026 4
- Rationale 4
- Table 1 Objectives and PAs of the Accelerating Uzbekistans Transition DPO 4
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 5
- PDO3 - To support a faster and more equitable economic transition through increased economic and social inclusion especially of women and persons with disabilities PA5 PA6 PA7 5
- PDO1 To support a faster and more equitable economic transition through stronger market institutions and better management of state-owned enterprises. 5
- PA1 Relevance of PA1 Highly Satisfactory HS 5
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 6
- Uzbekistan Public Expenditure Review 6
- PA2 Highly Satisfactory HS 6
- Principles of Corporate Governance 6
- PDO2 - To support a faster and more equitable economic transition through improved fiscal transparency and accountability. 6
- Public Expenditure Review 6
- PA3 Highly Satisfactory HS 6
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 7
- PA4 Highly Satisfactory HS 7
- PDO3 - To support a faster and more equitable economic transition through increased economic and social inclusion especially of women and persons with disabilities. 7
- Towards Full and Productive Employment in Uzbekistan Evolution of Employment Protection Legislation in the USSR CIS and Baltic States propiska 7
- PA5 Highly Satisfactory HS. 7
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 8
- PA6 Satisfactory S. 8
- Listening to the Citizens of Uzbekistan Survey 8
- PA7 Moderately Satisfactory MS 8
- Rating 8
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 9
- 4. Relevance of Results Indicators 9
- Rationale 9
- Table 2 RIs by Objective and PAs baseline and target values status and achievement 9
- PDO1 - To support a faster and more equitable economic transition through stronger market institutions and better management of state-owned enterprises. 9
- RI1 9
- RI2 9
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 10
- RI3 10
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 11
- PDO2 - To support a faster and more equitable economic transition through improved fiscal transparency and accountability. 11
- RI4 11
- RI5 11
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 12
- RI6 12
- PDO3 - To support a faster and more equitable economic transition through increased economic and social inclusion especially of women and persons with disabilities. 12
- RI7 12
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 13
- RI8 13
- RI9 13
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 14
- Note Achievement ratings in brackets reflect ratings achievement that may be adjusted based on relevance of the RIs in the Efficacy section Section 5. 14
- PDO1 - To support a faster and more equitable economic transition through stronger market institutions and better management of state-owned enterprises. 14
- RI1 Highly Satisfactory HS 14
- RI2 Highly Satisfactory HS 14
- RI3 Moderately Unsatisfactory MU 14
- Uzbekistan Second Systematic Country Diagnostic - Toward a Prosperous and Sustainable Future 14
- PDO2 - To support a faster and more equitable economic transition through improved fiscal transparency and accountability. 14
- RI4 14
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 15
- Unsatisfactory U 15
- RI5 Satisfactory S 15
- RI6 Satisfactory S 15
- WB 2024 Trends in Allocation and Impact Reporting Ensuring Transparency in Emerging Market Sovereign Green Social and Sustainability Bonds 15
- PDO3 - To support a faster and more equitable economic transition through increased economic and social inclusion especially of women and persons with disabilities. 15
- RI7 Moderately Unsatisfactory MU 15
- RI8 Satisfactory S 15
- RI9 15
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 16
- Moderately Unsatisfactory MU. 16
- Rating 16
- 5. Achievement of Objectives Efficacy 16
- Objective 16
- Rationale 16
- RI1 High 16
- RI2 Substantial 16
- RI3 16
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 17
- Striving for Progress 17
- Modest. 17
- Rating 17
- Objective 17
- Rationale 17
- RI4 Substantial 17
- Climate Budget Tagging in Uzbekistan Methodology and Implementation Roadmap Climate Public Expenditure and Institutional Review Uzbekistan negligible 17
- RI5 17
- MTDS 2023-2025 Medium-Term Fiscal Strategy for 2023-2025 The State Debt of the Republic of Uzbekistan for 2022 MTDS 2025-2027 17
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 18
- High 18
- RI6 High 18
- Uzbekistan July 2021 SDG Bond Allocation and Impact Report 18
- Rating 18
- Objective 18
- Rationale 18
- RI7 18
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 19
- Substantial. 19
- RI8 High 19
- RI9 Modest 19
- Rating 19
- Overall Achievement of Objectives Efficacy Rationale 19
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 20
- Overall Efficacy Rating 20
- 6. Outcome 20
- Rationale 20
- 7. Risk to Development Outcome 20
- Republic of Uzbekistan - Staff Report for the 2024 Article IV Consultation 20
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 21
- 8. Assessment of Bank Performance 21
- Rationale 21
- Stand-Alone Operation. 21
- Analytical Underpinning. 21
- Central Asias Horticulture Sector Uzbekistan Second Agricultural Public Expenditure Review Assessing Uzbekistans Transition 21
- Gender Discrimination in Hiring Evidence 21
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 22
- Setting a National Poverty Line in Uzbekistan Listening to the Citizens of Uzbekistan Survey UN Common Country Analysis Uzbekistan Uzbekistan Disability Inclusion 22
- Links to Related WB Operations. 22
- Collaboration with Development Partners. 22
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 23
- Republic of Uzbekistan Debt Sustainability Analysis Uzbekistan July 2021 SDG Bond Allocation and Impact Report 23
- Implementation Risks and Mitigation Measures. 23
- Shortcomings at Design 23
- Rating 23
- Rationale 23
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 24
- Monitoring. 24
- Technical Assistance. 24
- Coordination with Development Partners. 24
- Follow-On Operations. 24
- Rating 24
- Rationale 24
- Overall Bank Performance Rating 24
- 9. Other Impacts 24
- Social and Poverty 24
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 25
- Environmental 25
- Gender 25
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 26
- Women Business and the Law 2024 26
- 10. Quality of ICR 26
- Rationale 26
- 11. Ratings 26
- Ratings ICR IEG Reason for DisagreementComments 26
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 27
- 12. Lessons 27
- 13. Project Performance Assessment Report PPAR Recommended 27
