We examine the mental wellbeing of the young in 18 Latin American countries using data from five cross-country comparative studies plus cross-sectional and quarterly time series data for a single country, Mexico. We examine whether there has been a decline in youth mental health and, if so, whether it has removed the U-shape in happiness and the hump-shape in unhappiness in Latin America as it has done in the United States and elsewhere. In the Global Minds data, the mental health of the young is poorer than that of older age groups. The Enbiare surveys for Mexico indicate that declining wellbeing of the young has changed the age profile of (un)happiness in that country. The OECD’s Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA) data show a decline in the mental health of school children in Latin America, and that mental ill-health is more pronounced among those who have early access to, or spend excessive time spent on, digital devices. However, in both the Gallup World Poll and the Latinobarometers the young remain happier than older age groups, even though the wellbeing of the young has declined in some Latin American countries. We speculate as to why there may be differences in trends across surveys.
Authors
Related Organizations
- Acknowledgements & Disclosure
- David G. Blanchflower and Alex Bryson would like to thank the United Nations for support. The copyright for all research commissioned by the Human Development Report Office will be held by UNDP. We thank the ESRC Data Archive for access to the data. We thank Gabe Gottesman and Noah Durham for research assistance and Carol Graham, Jon Haidt, Christina Lengfelder, Bruce Sacerdote and Tara Thiagarajan for useful comments and Mariano Rojas for help with the data. The views expressed herein are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Bureau of Economic Research.
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.3386/w33111
- Pages
- 61
- Published in
- United States of America
Table of Contents
- NBER WORKING PAPER SERIES 1
- THE MENTAL HEALTH OF THE YOUNG IN LATIN AMERICA 1
- David G. Blanchflower Alex Bryson 1
- Working Paper 33111 httpwww.nber.orgpapersw33111 1
- NATIONAL BUREAU OF ECONOMIC RESEARCH 1050 Massachusetts Avenue Cambridge MA 02138 November 2024 1
- The Mental Health of the Young in Latin America David G. Blanchflower and Alex Bryson NBER Working Paper No. 33111 November 2024 JEL No. I31 J13 2
- Alex Bryson Professor of Quantitative Social Science UCL Social Research Institute University College London 55-59 Gordon Square London WC1H 0AL United Kingdom a.brysonucl.ac.uk 2
- 1. Introduction 3
- 2. Wellbeing in Latin America 2.1 How does Latin America Differ from the West 5
- 2.2 Wellbeing in Latin America 7
- 2.3 Wellbeing of The Young in Latin America 9
- 3. Data and Estimation 3.1 Data 3.1.1 Gallup World Poll 2005-2023 3.1.2 Latinobarometer 1997-2023 10
- 3.1.3 World Values Surveys 1981-2022 3.1.4 Enbiare Surveys for Mexico 3.1.5 Global Minds 2020-2024 11
- 3.1.6 Programme for International Student Assessment PISA 2022 12
- 3.2 Estimation 4. Results 4.1. Time series changes in country rankings in wellbeing in Latin America 13
- 4.1. Gallup World Poll 2005-2022 14
- 4.2. Latinobarometers. 1997-2023 15
- 4.3. World Values Survey 1981-2022 4.4. Enbiare surveys for Mexico 16
- 4.5. Global Minds 2020-2024 Mental State of the World in 2023 4.6 Internet and cell phone usage 17
- 4. Conclusions 19
- References 23
- Uruguay -0.12 35
- Bolivia -0.12 35
- Mexico -0.06 35
- Colombia -0.67 35
- Peru -0.01 Honduras 0.70 35
- Chile -0.60 35
- Brazil -0.59 35
- Ecuador 0.07 Paraguay 35
- Venezuela -0.39 35
- Costa Rica -0.34 35
- Argentina -0.32 35
- Nicaragua 0.30 35
- Guatemala -0.21 35
- Panama -0.19 35
- El Salvador 0.43 35
- Dominican Republic 0.43 35
- Chart 1. USA Life satisfaction USA - source BRFSS 50
- Chart 2. USA Despair 2010 and 2023 - Source BRFSS 51
- Chart 3. Latin America Cantril life satisfaction from Gallup World Poll 52
- Chart 4. Worry in Latin America from the Gallup World Poll 2005-2022 53
- Chart 5. Latin American Internet usage population share 54
- Chart 6a. Latin America cell phone subscriptions per 100 population 55
- Chart 6b. Latin America cell phone subscriptions 100 population 56