Authors
- Disclosure Date
- 2024/11/13
- Disclosure Status
- Disclosed
- Doc Name
- Mongolia - MN-Ulaanbaatar Clean Air
- Lending Instrument
- Investment Project Financing
- Pages
- 22
- Product Line
- IBRD/IDA
- Published in
- United States of America
- Rel Proj ID
- MN-Ulaanbaatar Clean Air Project -- P122320
- TF No/Name
- TF0A7786-Support to the Preparation of Electricity for Heating Program in Ulaanb,TF0A9147-UBCAP Staff Grant for Mr. Inchul Hwang
- Unit Owning
- INF-EAP-Energy (IEAE1)
- Version Type
- Final
Table of Contents
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 1
- 1. Project Data 1
- Project ID Project Name 1
- Country Practice AreaLead 1
- LCTF Numbers Closing Date Original Total Project Cost USD 1
- Bank Approval Date Closing Date Actual 1
- IBRDIDA USD Grants USD 1
- Prepared by Reviewed by ICR Review Coordinator Group 1
- 2. Project Objectives and Components 1
- DEVOBJTBL a. Objectives 1
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 2
- Did the Board approve the revised objectiveskey associated outcome targets 2
- Date of Board Approval 2
- Ger Area Particulate Matter Mitigation 2
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 3
- Central Ulaanbaatar UB Particulate Matter Mitigation 3
- Mitigation of Fugitive Dust from lack of City Greening 3
- Mitigation of dust from Power Plant Emissions and Ash Ponds 3
- District Heating Feasibility Study and Knowledge Building 3
- Affordable Housing Policy Technical Assistance 3
- Public Awareness Raising Program Coordination and Project Management 3
- Air Quality Monitoring Management and Analysis 3
- Program Coordination Support 3
- Project Management Public Awareness and Monitoring and Evaluation 3
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 4
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 5
- Electricity for Heating in Targeted Ger Areas 5
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 6
- 3. Relevance of Objectives 6
- Rationale 6
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 7
- Rating 7
- 4. Achievement of Objectives Efficacy 7
- OBJECTIVE 1 7
- Objective 7
- Rationale 7
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 8
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 9
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 10
- Rating 10
- OBJECTIVE 1 REVISION 1 10
- Revised Objective 10
- Revised Rationale 10
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 11
- Revised Rating 11
- OBJECTIVE 2 11
- Objective 11
- Rationale 11
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 12
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 13
- Rating 13
- OBJECTIVE 2 REVISION 1 13
- Revised Objective 13
- Revised Rationale 13
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 14
- Revised Rating 14
- OVERALL EFFICACY 14
- Rationale 14
- Overall Efficacy Rating 14
- OVERALL EFFICACY REVISION 1 14
- Overall Efficacy Revision 1 Rationale 14
- Overall Efficacy Revision 1 Rating 14
- 5. Efficiency 14
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 15
- Efficiency Rating 15
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 16
- Rate Available Point value CoverageScope 16
- 6. Outcome 16
- Outcome Rating 16
- 7. Risk to Development Outcome 16
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 17
- 8. Assessment of Bank Performance 17
- Quality-at-Entry Rating 17
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 18
- Quality of Supervision Rating 18
- Overall Bank Performance Rating 18
- 9. ME Design Implementation Utilization 18
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 19
- ME Quality Rating 19
- 10. Other Issues 19
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 20
- 11. Ratings 20
- Ratings ICR IEG Reason for DisagreementsComment 20
- 12. Lessons 20
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 21
- 13. Assessment Recommended 21
- 14. Comments on Quality of ICR 21
- Independent Evaluation Group IEG 22
